Scinde Dawk - Asia first stamp - Stamp Expert Certificate - Is it forgery stamp or never issued.

Scinde Dawk 1852 stamps from India was sold for $1025 by eBay seller "lunar_nj" from India and item location in Kansas, USA.

Not sure where seller will pay capital gain tax ?

Because seller is based in India and item location in USA.

Need to pay too lot of capital gain tax on this item as it was sold for $1025.

But my question is this all real.?

All means

• Embossed Scinde Dawk is genuine stamp ? (any one can make this kind of embossed stamp and start applying on old paper)
• Do you think after 167+ years this kind of thing still available in plenty. ( I had seen more than 200 on eBay alone in last 9 years).
• Do you think this is genuine transaction where eBay seller paid all commission to eBay?
• Do you think eBay seller paid all state tax (kansas) and federal tax to IRS ?
• Do you think this stamp Expert certificate as any value? (anyone can issue Expert Certificate as no licenses or education required.!!)
• Do people were using stamps 167+ years ago.? (Think how far your relatives were living at that time.!!)
• Do you think it was never issued.? ( do you think it was required in India or Pakistan when it was under British rule).
• Do you think piece of paper will still remain intact after 167+ years ago? (think about weather, all different wars in that region and other things happened in 167 years. Do you have your first standard marksheet?)
• Do people collect stamp anymore? 
• Do you think 43 bids are genuine?
• One bidder is bidding on 832 items and 5721 bids? ( can you believe that.!)
• Do you think SHILL bidding is done to increase price?

After reading all of the above Will you pay $1025 for this kind piece of paper ?

Want to do more research  then click following link to read about Scinde Dawk.

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/search/label/scinde%20dawk

2 months ago Scinde Dawk with Stamp Expert Certificate from RPSL Ltd was sold for $999 by "invest-and-collect" from UK with only one bid.!!

Why only one bid and less price then "lunar_nj"

Do you think this stamps are Investment ?

Do you think it's invest and collect item?

Above screenshot is about bidder who is bidding on Scinde Dawk but also bidding on another 832 items on eBay with 5721 bids.!!


What do you think about this bidder ?

Is it SHILL bidding ?

Thanks
GSC

China PRC stamp - 1967 Mao stamp on envelope cover - China stamps investment.

China PRC stamp - 1967 Mao stamp on envelope cover was sold for $4750 by eBay seller "jumapo60"  from Portugal. 

Do you think this is genuine China PRC stamp of 1967 Mao stamp on envelope cover and send it to Budapest ?

Reason for this is it was very hard to send anything outside China in 1967 because of communist rule.

It's very hard to find whether this is genuine but it's easy to consider as forgery ?

We know how easy is to make forgery cover in today's world and sell it on ebay like we saw in 2009 from Winnenden Germany. If it can happen in Germany it can happen in anywhere at anytime.

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2010/01/fake-gandhi-postmark-cancel-from.html

Above is BOGUS (never exist) rubber stamp. They try to make it as if it was issued by German postal service.!!

It's not forgery because there was none like this issued.!! It's BOGUS rubber stamp like kids use to make artwork.

But it's an ART of Making Money.!!

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2013/01/art-of-making-money-philately-greed.html

Just make rubber stamp  like above and apply it on any old cover available in stamp exhibition.!! 

My personal opinion is that following is forgery rubber stamp from China. (Who will know what happen in 1967 in communist country.!!)

My personal opinion is that this cover was made with some old cover send to Budapest from some other country as there is no address of sender.!!

Now fix some stamp and fake rubber stamp with Chinese date stamp.!!

Do you really think this was sold for $4750.?

I don't think so because

• No one collect stamp anymore
• SHILL bidding is used to increase price by stamp dealer and other philatelic collector
• eBay got commission on this transaction ? (10% of selling price.!!)

All you see is not real.

It's nothing but glorification of China stamp collection so some new guy will invest in stamps after advice from investment advisor as alternative investment in chinese stamps.!!

Still don't believe then read all of the following and think with your own brain.!!

Following is taken from Gandhi Stamps Club which are mostly all BOGUS (never exist) or Forgery which will help you to decide about slogan cancellation of Gandhi "Truth is God"

1) India 1911 Allahabad First Aerial Mail Post Commemorative cancel or Special cancellation 

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2012/07/first-aerial-post-indian-philately.html

2) India 1937 Rocket Mail Commemorative cancel or Special cancellation 

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2013/01/india-rocket-mail.html

3) India 1947 Jai Hind Cancellation

India First Day Independence cover Jai Hind Slogan Special Cancellation.

4) 1948 Chalta Dak Ghar Commemorative cancel or Special cancellation 

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2012/12/king-george-stamps.html

5) India 1948 Gandhi stamp First Day cover Jai Hind Commemorative cancel or Special cancellation (Biggest Forgery in single individual stamp collection).

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2013/02/gandhi-stamps-and-1948-jai-hind-special.html

6) 1969 Fiji, Luxembourg, Burma, Czech Republic Commemorative cancel or Special cancellation  (wide varieties available)

God knows which is Genuine and Which one is forgery !!

God knows which of this were even issued officially by postal department ?

Don't you think there are multiple rubber stamps from multiple collectors.!!?

Not sure whether this are BOGUS (never issued), but made to handbooks and yearbooks or exhibit.

                    http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2013/04/luxembourg-postmark.html

7) India 1969  "FLAG DAY 1st October Help Ex Servicemen"

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2014/08/commemorative-cancel-special.html

8) Bogus (never exist) 2009 Germany Winnenden Commemorative cancel or Special cancellation issued for High School shooting for Non Violence.!! (No respect for who died during this school shooting).


http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2010/01/fake-gandhi-postmark-cancel-from.html

Click following link to read more about BLUM case and OPEN YOUR EYES.!! There are 650 forged rubber stamps from Germany  and think about chances of forged from INDIA or China or any other countries.!!

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2011/06/fake-ffc-flown-in-airbus-a380-with.html

All of the below are FORGERY.!! 

http://www.filatelia.fi/forgeries/blum.html

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2013/11/china-stamp-collection-value.html


So what do you think. Can we add this in above list.

It's all about MONEY. How to get your money.!!

To know more about this kind of activity read my following blog post and think what are the possibilities in cheating, glorification, SHILL bidding, FAKE, Forgery etc.

1) 1948 Stamps False hope of Riches?
2) 1948 Gandhi Stamps: Are False hope of Riches - Part II ?
3) 1948 Gandhi Mourning Private FDC : Are False hope of Riches - Part III?
4) 1948 Expensive Gandhi FDC : Are False hope of Riches - Part IV?
5) 1948 Gandhi Stamps Early Usage cover :  Gandhi Stamps Are False hope of Riches - Part V?
6) Maxi Card sold for $5100 with 1948 Gandhi Stamps - False hope of Riches - Part VI?
7) Indian Philately Exposed 
8) Indian Philately Exposed - Part II
9) Gandhi SERVICE overprint stamp price fell from $1009 to $1.!!
10) How can you tell that Gandhi SERVICE stamp is FAKE or Forgery ?

So what are chances of this cover is forgery.?

I am not an expert so I cannot say it's forgery or it's genuine.

But you can see how easy is to make rubber stamp and apply on any piece of paper and call it as Philatelic material.!!

It's your money.!!

Thanks
GSC

Rich Chinese stamp investment. in China PRC stamps - China Taiwan 1962 Chinese painting Emperors stamps

China PRC stamps - China Taiwan 1962 Chinese painting Emperors  stamps sold on eBay for $10100 by eBay seller "australia-ox-deals".

Do you think this is genuine stamps ? 

May be not even exist as no one knows what happen in 1962 in communist country so you can print it and sell it.!!

Do you think it's a genuine price ?

SHILL bidding may be possibility as it's easy to open account and start bidding on your own auction.!! or other dealers and collector also increase price as you don't have to pay until you win.

There are 20 bidders and 53 bids (private listing).!!

• Unknown new collector wins then he has to pay and regret it,.
• If other dealer or collector wins he will not pay and seller will cancel transaction so don't have to pay commission to eBay.
• If  SHILL bidder wins he will also not pay and open case with eBay for non payment and don't have to pay commission.

What you see on eBay is not correct price. eBay is not regulated by any government like stock exchange.  U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission is responsible for any wrong trade or illegal trade or anything like insider trading or fake price on US stock exchange such as Dow or Nasdaq.

So do you think this is

GENUINE priced ?

eBay got commission on this. ?

Australian government got VAT on this as per there new online VAT law ?

Did Australian government got Income Tax and other taxes on this high amount collectible items which might also include capital gain tax. ?

So my personal opinion after following things I saw in last 9+ years in stamp collecting and after writing 700+ blogs

• No one collect stamps anymore.
• SHILL bidding is only way to increase price
• Stamp dealers are looking . for Chinese rich people to invest in stamps.!!
• Forgery, FAKE and BOGUS (never exist) stamps are selling everywhere in order to make money for China & India as there was not much info available.

So my personal opinion is that this is not valued to $10000.!! 

This opinion is like Expert stamp certification who don't take any responsibility even after getting money. 

Here I am giving it free.

If you are rich chinese then you are fooled by some investment advisor to invest in stamp then go for it. It's your money.!!

Let stamp dealer and investment banker become rich and you regret once you know realty.!!

Thanks

GSC.

Note :

China PRC stamps - China Taiwan 1962 Chinese painting Emperors  was sold for $12200 on Jan 13, 2019.!!

15 -18% price reduction in 15 days.!!

with 21 bidders and 82 bids.

Indian postal history - India 1852 Scinde Dawk stamp - Indian Philately

Indian postal history - India 1852 Scinde Dawk stamp - Indian Philately was sold on eBay for $1382 by seller "lunar_nj" (241) from India but item location in Kansas USA.

Now we all know what Indian Postal history. It is nothing but FORGERY or BOGUS (never exist) philately material.

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2014/09/scinde-dawk-postal-history-first.html

Do you think this is GENUINE stamp ?

We know how easy is to make stamps and no one will notice it or even don't know whether was really exist.

In this Scinde Dawk you just need a custom embossed seal which can be made for $20-40 and you can start making money.!!

This Scinde Dawk will be easiest to FORGE as it don't need any color combination or performating cutting!!

Also who knows which is genuine or forged as there is no Genuine.!!

This Indian postal history of  India 1852 Scinde Dawk stamp is 165+ years old and still selling in large quantity. In last 10 years I had seen almost more 200 were sold.!!

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2018/04/scinde-dawk-1852-stamp.html (sold for $1700 by "dm_stamps" from Sunnyvale, CA)

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2013/01/scinde-dawk-stamps.html (sold for $3000 by "staucy" from UK)

http://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2018/04/scinde-dawk-alternative-investment-in.html (sold for $6200 by "pristinephilatelics" from Sunnyvale, CA)

Just 3 eBay transaction were for $10000+ (lot of money for eBay as well as Sunnyvale,CA and Federal tax from just transaction as EU)

In this Indian postal history of  India of 1852 Scinde Dawk stamp on eBay there were 59 bids and 10 bidders as if there is lot of interest.

Anyone can bid on eBay even though they don't have money in account with any number of ebay accounts.!!

We know when price or # of bids are more then there is always SHILL bidding to increase the price.

https://gandhistampsclub.blogspot.com/2015/12/uk-vat-on-collectors-item-and.html

So what do you think about Shill bidding  in this Indian postal history of  India 1852 Scinde Dawk stamp ?

But it's still lot of money even after paying commision to eBay and Kansas state tax and USA federal tax as location is in Kansas USA.

Do you think seller has to pay tax in USA or India ?

So now what do you think about Indian postal history of India 1852 Scinde Dawk stamp  a classic  Indian Philately?

• Genuine or Forgery stamp? 
• Really sold for $1352 ? 
• Shill bidding happened in this eBay transaction ?
• Did eBay got commission on this Scinde Dawk?
• Where seller has to pay taxes ? In USA or India ?
• Is it legal for eBay seller based in India to sell from USA ?

You know my opinion. 

This is nothing but false hope of riches.!!

Thanks

GSC